Proposed Development Plan
1/23/15 Dakota County is in the process of updating its master plan for Lebanon Hills Regional Park with a controversial development plan. After the 60-day public comment period ended in January 2014, the County Commissioners redirected the process to include a Citizen Advisory Panel. The panel had until December 31, 2014 to review and comment on specific elements of the 2014 draft plan. On 1/13/15 the Dakota County Board directed county staff to revise the draft plan and put it open for public comment. The County Board is expected to vote on the plan in March 2015.
The revised Plan for Lebanon Hills Regional Park is online, at all Dakota County library branches, and at the Lebanon Hills Visitor Center. The 30 day public comment period is now open and will end on Feb 25th.
Recap of 1/13 Dakota County Board Committee Meeting
The Dakota County Board of Commissioners voted unanimously to accept the Lebanon Hills Citizen Panel Final Report and direct staff to revise the controversial draft plan, per staff recommendations, some of which are:
- The preferred Connector surface is bituminous asphalt and the preferred width is 10 feet.
- Lebanon Hills should provide basic recreation that County residents seek elsewhere now, e.g., easy walking, jogging, ADA-accessible trails, recreation biking for all ages and abilities.
- Redesign the middle park soft trails as multi-use (shared horse- hike).
- Share horse trails in the southeast park area with hikers (high priority).
Minority Report Submitted
A Minority Report was submitted to the Board of Commissioners by panel member, Holly Jenkins. “The Citizen Advisory Panel was not established to participate in the process of updating the 2001 Master Plan…the Panel was created and proceedings controlled in a manner that would enable Dakota County to change the direction Lebanon Hills was heading…”
Staff will revise the controversial draft plan, followed by a 30-day public review and comment period.
Wilderness in the City will send notice as soon as revised draft plan is available.
Commissioners will consider final plan adoption in March 2015.
What You Can Do
Dakota County Board of Commissioners retains full authority and discretion to adopt the development master plan as it deems appropriate. Comments are valuable for public record and the future of Lebanon Hills.
- Submit comments to: email@example.com AND CC: firstname.lastname@example.org Online comments must be received by planning department to be included in public record.
- Submit comments to Individual Commissioners NOTE: New Commissioner for LAKEVILLE residents.
- Comment directly to the Board at their 1/20 meeting.
- CONTINUE TO INFORM OTHERS.
Lebanon Hills Controversy in the Press
Paving paradise? Some parkgoers oppose Lebanon Hills plan
Star Tribune, 12/10/14
Final Citizen Panel Report
A final report will be submitted to the Board of Commissioners by end of year.
The Citizen Panel was directed to review and comment on certain elements of the 2014 draft development plan and report to the county board on consensus basis the results of the Panel’s review and comment.
The board will consider these comments but is not obligated to adopt any consensus recommendations reported by the panel or to give panel recommendations any particular weight relative to other information provided to them from other members of the public, organization, entities and its own staff and consultants.
The County Board, your elected representatives, retains full authority and discretion to adopt the plan.
Citizen Panel Influence
The Lebanon Hills Citizen Panel operational guidelines state that the Dakota County Board retains full authority and discretion to adopt the master plan, and is not obligated to give panel recommendations any particular weight relative to other information provided to the board from its own staff and consultants or other members of the public.
Click the image to give to Wilderness in the City.
Give to the Max day is Thursday, November 13, but you can ‘beat the rush’ by making a scheduled gift today. Give it a try! We hope you’ll feel good knowing that you are supporting our work to preserve urban natural spaces like Lebanon Hills Regional Park. All donations are tax deductible.
Summary of Citizen Advisory Panel Meetings 4-7Natural Resource Restoration
Meetings 5, 6, & 7 – Trails Overview
Natural Resource Restoration (meeting 4)
WHAT THEY SAY: Approximately $650,000 per year is projected for Stewardship Spending in Lebanon Hills beginning in 2015. ~ paid consultant to panel members, 7/17/14.
WHAT THEY DO: Projected Natural Resource spending for the entire Dakota County park system is $511,000 per year from 2015-2018, 4.6% of the total park budget. ~ Proposed 2015-2019 Parks and Greenways [Trails] Budget
Reality Check:The County has proposed less stewardship spending for the entire park system then what they projected for Lebanon Hills alone.
More Information: The 2001 plan established firm guidelines — “As decisions are made regarding implementation and funding strategies, all four implementation categories [ecological stewardship, water resources, acquisition, development] will be of equal priority.” ( 2001 Master Plan, p. S.6) Even with these guidelines, the County spent 4 times more on development then on ecological stewardship.
By comparison, the draft 2013 development plan has no guidelines for funding and implementation of natural resource projects relative to development projects. That means there is no accountability for the county to prioritize funding or implementation of natural resource stewardship.
Alternate Suggestion: To assure natural resources are given adequate consideration in years ahead, all master plan updates should include the implementation categories and priorities which were established and approved in the 2001 master plan.
Trails Overview (Meetings 5, 6, 7)
Connector Trail Comparison: proposed 2013 Corridor through the middle of park with No Build option. ~ paid consultant to panel members, 8/21/14
WHAT THEY SAY:
1. Environmental Sensitivity: Both options rated equally as “Best”.
Reality Check: Proposed 2013 Connector Trail: 30′ to 80′ wide clearance of woodlands and prairies for 6.5 miles (24 to 63 acres); undisclosed amounts of cut and fill for grading; building of retaining walls and additional support structures; snow/ice removal through park’s ecological systems.
2. Cost: Both options rated equally as “Best”.
Reality Check: $3,373,500 estimated cost for Connector Trail (2013 Draft Development Plan, p. 166). Estimated annual expense for maintenance and eventual replacement has not been provided. Dakota County will be responsible for the undisclosed ongoing annual expenses.
Why the County needs a Connector Trail in the park:
WHAT THEY SAY: Paved trails will offer more recreational opportunities and allow better access for the elderly, mobility disabled, and moms with strollers.
WHAT THEY DO: Plan a commuter road-like trail for bike speeds up to 20mph.
Reality Check: Dakota County is “opportunistic” with regard to funding. Money sources for trails include State and Federal transportation funds. ~ Steve Sullivan, Dakota County Parks Director, to panel members (9/25/14)
- Regional Bike Trails are eligible for State and Federal Transportation Funds if they meet strict criteria.
- Criteria include: 10-12′ wide asphalt with additional width for curves; 2′ mowed zone on either side; additional clearance for sight-lines of 150′; 5% grade; free of snow and ice; intended for transportation and recreation.
- 2013 proposed Connector Trail meets the criteria for transportation funding.
- Lebanon Hills is envisioned as the Hub of Dakota County’s planned regional trail network.
More Information: Trails planned for recreation-only have no strict criteria which allows for greater flexibility when designing trails for all abilities, less environmental impact, and lower annual costs.
- 2001 connector trail: Planned as a recreation trail to connect park amenities; designed to keep in character with the park.
- 2013 connector trail: Planned as part of the county’s Regional Trail Network for bike speeds up to 20mph; designed to meet criteria for transportation funding.
Alternate Suggestion: Trails designed for bicycle commuting speeds of 20 mph should connect to, but not be constructed through, Lebanon Hills. Trails within Lebanon Hills should accommodate only passive recreation, not transportation.
- Paid consultants present different parts of the plan and ask for comments, the same format as the public open houses.
- The plan has not been changed in response to previous public comments.
- The panel is not charged with anything more than making comments.
- The final decision is up to the Board of Commissioners — your elected representatives.
Our Goal Remains – Meaningful Citizen Involvement in creating the master plan update prior to its adoption.
Citizen Panel Meetings
November LHRP Citizen Advisory Panel meeting #9
Thursday, 11/13, 6pm, Location TBD
- Agenda: Recreational Use Areas and Connector Trail
– Meeting is open to the public. There is no opportunity for comments.
Final Meetings Schedule
- Thurs, 11/13 — Recreational Use Areas and Connector Trail
- One more meeting is being added , yet to be scheduled.
Citizen Panel Posts – all our meeting agenda, recap, and summary posts:
7/11/14 – After three panel meetings, our evaluation of the process
7/11/14 – Notice of fourth panel meeting & agenda
6/15/14 – Recap of second panel meeting
6/10/14 – Notice of second panel meeting & agenda
6/5/14 – Recap of first panel meeting
4/30/14 – Notice of panel facilitator hiring
4/9/14 – Advisory panel appointments by County Commissioners